Ask an expert

I am trying to find a replacement for my current car which I have owned for 12 years. I want something safe and fuel efficient and am considering a 2004 1.6 litre Toyota Corolla.

Also, I was going to buy from an auction because the car dealers prices seem higher.

Could you please tell me;

1. Are there any other models other than the Toyota you can recommend?
2. Is buying through an auction a good move?

Rosemary

From the "Ask Jack" archives - 14 December 2009

The 2004 Corolla would fit the bill perfectly, in that it is both economical and according to our Used Car Safety rating survey, provides higher than average crash protection.

That said, it's not the most exciting vehicle in the world and the 1.6 litre Corolla of that age would be a used import as to my knowledge all NZ new Corollas were 1.8 litre in 2004.

The 1.6 may not offer the economy you think as the Corolla is a good size hatchback and the smaller engine might struggle a little at times and end up using the same or more fuel as the bigger engine.

Check the rear centre seat belt as well. It may be a lap belt only whereas the NZ new should have a full lap and diagonal restraint fitted.

I'd try to stick with a New Zealand new Corolla to be honest. This will increase your chance of buying a car with a good service history and better suited for our environment.

Another option would be the Mazda3 (NZ new), which is an exciting car to drive with sporty looks. There are no major known problems (slight road noise?). Its resale value should hold up pretty well when it comes to re-sale time also.

The Nissan Pulsar of similar age would also be a good all round choice.

To maximise reliability and economy I would opt for a manual gearbox especially if you intend on holding onto the car as long as the last one. Not always practical but they are pretty much bullet proof.

Most auction houses have a reputable name but you need to ensure you know exactly what you want and look specifically for that make and model.

With an auction you're restricted at times to what's on offer which may mean a compromise and you can get caught up in all the hype.

Don't give up on car dealers totally as it's a buyer's market right now and I would be surprised if they were not prepared to negotiate a discounted price.

Wherever or whatever you buy, I would strongly recommend a pre-purchase inspection for added piece of mind.